The Daily Star, Oneonta, NY - otsego county news, delaware county news, oneonta news, oneonta sports


May 25, 2013

I can't make up my mind on the death penalty

If there’s a silver lining from three of the most horrific crimes in recent memory, it’s that we have the perpetrators in custody.

Ariel Castro, the man accused of kidnapping and brutalizing a trio of young women for the past decade in Cleveland, now amuses himself pacing and sweeping the floor of his cell while awaiting trial.

Boston bombing suspect Dzhokar Tsarnaev also now lives in a prison, recovering from gunshot wounds suffered at the hands of his pursuers.

And convicted pedophile David Renz of Syracuse is locked up after allegedly slicing his monitoring bracelet to kidnap a mother and her 10-year-old daughter on their way home from gymnastics class, then fatally stab the former and rape the latter.

One of the most popular arguments I’ve heard against capital punishment comes only from laymen, and never from elected officials: that executions are too painless for creeps like Renz, who deserve instead to sit in a cell with “Bubba” for the rest of their lives.

That’s the sort of vigilante justice Renz felt in March, according to the Syracuse Post-Standard, after he apparently was put in a holding center with other prisoners intentionally by prison guards. Renz showed up in for a court appearance the next day with a swollen face and broken nose.

I’ve always held conflicting opinions about the death penalty, but I’ve never believed that it’s excessively cruel. Renz’s jailhouse beating gave similar contradictory thoughts.

If anyone deserves the ultimate punishment, it’s those who commit the sort of monstrous crimes of which Castro and Renz are accused. But although I have zero sympathy for Renz, vigilante justice among inmates has no place in the United States, given our Eighth Amendment ban on cruel and unusual punishment.

That said, if Castro and Renz are convicted but somehow manage to avoid execution, it would be hard for me to come away from their cases feeling that justice was served. For their victims, sentencing the perpetrators to death isn’t an act of vengeance so much as a matter of balancing the scales of justice.

Text Only
Big Chuck D'Imperio
Cary Brunswick

Chuck Pinkey
Guest Column

Lisa Miller

Mark Simonson

Rick Brockway

Sam Pollak
William Masters
  • Schreibman tops Chris Gibson on women's issues

    As the time to vote draws near, we need to remember how money can run politics more than we can. Raising funds is a prominent (if not the dominant) task of getting elected. Raising issues is also crucial, but those efforts are subject to distortion and fear-mongering.

    September 18, 2012

  • Republicans feelentitled to allthey can garner

    An entitlement is a legal benefit available from the government to individuals who are within a defined category of recipients, such as needing insurance for unemployment or health services.

    September 4, 2012

  • Romney focuses on self; Obama emphasizes unity

    Mitt Romney criticizes President Obama for saying a person's success is rooted in his community, and is not all his alone. Romney belittles this with his belief in individual initiative. He is better at the put-down than the push-up.

    August 21, 2012

  • Romney shows little regard for common man

    The Republicans in Congress have voted over and over, 33 times, redundantly and uselessly, to rescind what they call Obamacare.

    August 7, 2012

  • Scouts' gay ban creates problem where none exists

    The Boy Scouts of America's "emphatic reaffirmation" of its vow to exclude any and all homosexuals from its hallowed ranks is ill-considered and pathetic, especially in view of its having reviewed the matter for two years.

    July 24, 2012

Additional Content
Join the Debate
Additional Resources
CNHI News Service

Is Israel justified to conduct its military campaign against the Hamas in Gaza?

Undecided/no opinion
     View Results