The Daily Star, Oneonta, NY - otsego county news, delaware county news, oneonta news, oneonta sports

October 25, 2012

Court correct to uphold marriage law

The Daily Star

---- — It has been 15 months since New York state’s law legalizing same-sex marriages went into effect. Getting the bill through the Legislature took years of spadework and arm-twisting, and was accomplished with near-unanimous Democratic Party support and the courageous votes of four Republicans in the state Senate.

We have previously expressed regret in these columns that our local state senator, James Seward, was not among the four Republicans who put their political careers on the line in order to be on the right side of history.

Seward, in a conversation Tuesday with this newspaper’s editorial board, defended his “nay” vote by stating it reflected both his personal views and what he judged were those of his constituents. He said he did not regret opposing the law.

Still, when asked if “traditional marriage” had suffered any harm since the day the law went into effect, Seward smiled.

“Well,” he said, “the sun came up the next day.”

It was a tacit and generous admission that Seward had not seen any deleterious effect from the law on heterosexual married couples.

Would that everyone would be so gracious. A conservative group, New Yorkers for Constitutional Freedoms, brought a lawsuit that tried to restrict the rights of gay couples by virtue of a technicality.

The group claimed that because Senate Republicans held two closed-door meetings before the vote — one with Gov. Andrew Cuomo and the other with New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg — that the law should be overturned.

In July of this year, an appeals court unanimously ruled against the lawsuit, and the Constitutional Freedoms group then took its case to the state’s highest court, the Court of Appeals.

Thankfully, on Tuesday that court rejected the motion without explanation, refusing to hear the case and thus killing the only serious legal challenge to the law.

Cuomo praised the court in a statement.

“With the court’s decision, same-sex couples no longer have to worry that their right to marry could be legally challenged in this state. The freedom to marry in this state is secure for generations to come.”

Not surprisingly, the Rev. Jason J. McGuire, executive director of the Constitutional Freedoms group, reacted a bit differently in a statement.

“We’re disappointed, but not surprised, by today’s decision,” he said. “Every time the people of a state have had the opportunity to vote on this issue, they have rejected same-sex ‘marriage,’ but when rogue legislators and activist courts get involved they reject the will of the people.”

McGuire has it wrong. The people of New York have realized that the sun has indeed come up, and powered by freedom, it’s shining brighter than ever.