By Tom Grace
Cooperstown News Bureau
On Dec. 20, New Yorkers could find out what kind of new voting machines they’re getting, and how soon they’ll be installed.
On that date, federal District Judge Gary Sharpe of the Northern District of New York is scheduled to meet with federal Department of Justice lawyers and state elections officials.
The DOJ has sued New York for taking too long to install new, handicappedaccessible voting machines and has asked Sharpe to force the state to put a ballot- making device in every polling station next year.
These devices, known by brand names such as Auto- Mark, allow disabled voters to cast ballots independently. They come equipped with puff-sip, Braille and audio accessories meant to make voting easier for people with a variety of disabilities.
And they are meant to work with optical scanners, not computerized voting machines known as DREs, which have their own handicapped- accessible features.
For about three years, advocates of scanners and DREs have been vying for New York’s market, but Sharpe may have the last word, according to Lee Daghlian, a spokesman for the state Board of Elections.
``If we have to put a ballot- marking device in every polling place, I think that would be a nail in the coffin of the DRE,’’ Daghlian said Monday.
To put an AutoMark or similar device in every polling place would cost about $50 million of the $180 million in federal aid that New York has to transition to new equipment, said Daghlian.
With ballot markers already in place in 2008, most counties would probably opt to purchase scanners to make their systems complete and compliant with the federal Help America Vote Act.
Some counties might still opt for DREs, but the playing field would be tilted toward optical scanners, and the idea of scrapping about $50 million in equipment after one election cycle seems absurd, he said.
The DOJ has sued New York because it is the only state in the union that hasn’t replaced its lever voting machines, as mandated by HAVA. The lawsuit was launched in 2006, and the judge has already forced the state to install at least one ballot-marking device in every county.
Until about three weeks ago, it seemed New Yorkers would vote on their lever machines and a scattering of ballot markers through the 2008 presidential election, but then the DOJ asked the judge to speed up the process. Daghlian said the state Board of Elections has re- sponded by saying it could install more ballot markers in 2008 without putting one in every polling station.
According to current rules, elections commissioners in each county decide which kind of new voting machine the county will get. Otsego County Democratic Elections Commissioner Hank Nicols favors optical scanners as ``the only way to guarantee that votes will be counted accurately.’’
Because the paper ballots can be recounted by hand, if necessary, election results with the scanner system inspire confidence in the electoral system, he said.
However, Nicols said he doesn’t believe the county needs to install a ballotmarking device in every polling station.
``I think that would be an enormous waste of money,’’ he said. Most disabled people prefer to vote by absentee ballot, not in polling places, he said.
Nicols noted that only one disabled person cast a ballot with the county’s current ballot marker during the last election.
``With so few people wanting to use ballot markers, we’d be better off driving them in limos to use the one we have,’’ he said.
Disabilities advocate Chris Zachmeyer, executive director of the Catskill Center for Independence, noted that HAVA mandates that polling places have handicapped-accessible equipment ``and it says nothing about limousines.’’
H a n d i c a p p e d - a c c e s - sible equipment should be installed as soon as possible ``because that’s the law,’’ she said.
Zachmeyer said the ballot markers work well for people who are the blind, but not as well as DREs for people with dexterity and cognitive disabilities. Otsego County’s Republican Elections Commissioner Charlotte Koniuto, who has favored DREs, said she hopes Judge Sharpe does not force counties to install ballot markers in every polling station.
``The state hasn’t even certified which machines we will be able to buy eventually, so I think that would be a big mistake,’’ she said.
Daghlian said the state will begin testing voting machines in early 2008 with the goal of letting counties choose either DREs and optical scanners later in the year. If a county’s elections commissioners can’t agree on a machine, the state Board of Elections is empowered to make the choice for the county.
Sheila Ross, Otsego County’s Republican deputy elections commissioner, said the county could install new voting machines and train officials in time for the November 2008 election but couldn’t do it by the Feb. 5 presidential primary.
``That would be impossible,’’ she said.
2 Otsego officials oppose ballot markers at every site
By Tom Grace
- Local News
County officials object to logos on SAFE Act website
New York's new gun control law has hit another thicket of controversy, with three local sheriffs saying Monday they don't want their county's seals or logos used in a state website being designed for pistol permit recertification.
- Ithaca College student killed in Cobleskill crash
The address of a digital billboard was incorrect on a photo caption on Page 1 of Tuesday's Daily Star. The billboard is near I-88.
Rodney H. Ingalls
HARTWICK SEMINARY -- Rodney H. Ingalls died Nov. 19, 2013, at the age of 94. He lived a long and exemplary life.
- Remembering Remy in Milford
The campaign, on the St. Lawrence, from which so much has long, confidently, and reasonably expected, has ended far short of its object. ... The main army has taken post near St. Regis, for the winter; and ... the division under General Hampton is hutting on the Saranac.
Capital projects and audits and Redskins, oh my...
We are happy to report that we did indeed have a meeting with both the Superintendent of Schools and the Superintendent of Buildings and Grounds at CCS to discuss our questions and concerns about the proposed capital project. Plus we also had the opportunity to chat with the Business Manager regarding funding for the project. And for the most part we feel we now know more about the project although we still find ourselves musing about it.
Championship fever in Milford goes beyond Remy title
For Milford's boys, the Anton Remy Jr. Tournament title is only the beginning. "We want to win the Tri-Valley title and the Section Four title," junior point guard Will Ward said Saturday after the Wildcats took apart Franklin, 52-25, in the Remy finals.
- Much to love about walls
Volleyball team hopes to spike competition
Cooperstown has gotten used to volleyball success under Rich Jantzi, and it looks like CCS will prove themselves on the court again this year.
Wishing we would fall out of falling back
We all turned back our clocks on Sunday, Nov. 3 for Daylight Savings Time. But do you know why we do this?
Despite tournament loss, Wildcat girls look strong
Despite a 21-point loss to Harpursville in the finals of the Anton Remy Jr. Basketball Tournament on Saturday, the Wildcat girls are ready for a good season.
- Smithy play looking to tour
- 'A Christmas Carol' coming to The Farmers' Museum|
CV-S wins consolation games at Remy
Wyatt Crowley scored a game-high 19 points and had eight assists to lead Cherry-Valley Springfield to a consolation victory in the Anton Remy Tournament at Milford.
West honored for legion excellence
A local American Legion leader was honored Saturday for his years of service to local veterans and his community.
Bassett reducing psychiatric beds
Coping with a shortage of mental health providers, Bassett Medical Center is taking steps to reduce its 20-bed psychiatric unit to 10 beds effective Dec. 1, hospital officials have confirmed in response to inquires from The Daily Star.
- Chamber: Consumers should shop locally
Possible parole for local killer surprises family
Since her sister's murder in 1989, Jennifer Kirkpatrick has told her story again and again, each time re-living the nightmare. Now she is preparing to tell it again as the state Parole Board gets ready to consider the early release application of David Dart, now serving 25 years to life at medium-security Otisville state prison for Gibbons' murder.
- Officials: Keep murderer in jail
- County officials object to logos on SAFE Act website