subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Thu, Jul 09 2009 

Published: March 03, 2008 11:00 pm    print this story  

Sympathy for money borrowers unnecessary

The sky is falling! The sky is falling! What to do, what to do? So goes the mantra of the Bush administration, all the presidential candidates (except Huckabee) and both houses of Congress, especially those individuals running for re-election.

I am talking about the current subprime, adjustable rate mortgage "crisis." The solution is simple. Just follow the advice of Harvard Professor Gregory Mankiw, who was a former chair of the Council of Economics and do "absolutely nothing." This is a free-market system and will be solved within this system. Sure the economy is going to burp once or twice, and emotionally there will be wailing and gnashing of teeth. But, so what?

Even though the politicians and the bureaucrats are counting on your sympathy and compassion for those poor, innocent, naive borrowers who were defrauded by those big, old, mean lenders, don't let yourself get drawn in.

The real problem is a mix of falling housing prices, greedy lenders making bad business decisions, rising interest rates, easy credit granting policies and impatient borrowers not willing to live within their means.

It is certainly not solely the fault of the big, bad mortgage companies. Sure, they lent money to people who couldn't pay back the loans, but everyone thought the housing boom would go on forever.

Thus the banks would be covered with property worth more than the mortgage; and the lender, if the payments could not be met, could simply sell the home, pay off the loan and walk away with some equity in his pockets.

The last thing we need is for the federal government to come up with a solution, but that is exactly what it is trying to do. One proposal is for the Federal Housing Administration to refinance these risky mortgages for the low rate of 1 percent.

The Bush administration is for giving defaulters an additional 30 days before foreclosure proceedings begin. Hillary trumps that by suggesting a 90-day reprieve from foreclosure and also wants to freeze the rates of these mortgages for five years.

These are only a few of the solutions being offered. Unfortunately, of the 535 members of Congress, not a single one is a trained economist.

However, as congressmen, they should all know these efforts would be unconstitutional. These mortgages represent private contracts between borrower and lender. What right does the government have to just jump in and change the terms?

It is up to these two parties to solve the issues of refinancing, providing moratoriums or initiating foreclosure steps.

Yes, the lenders got greedy and made poor business decisions. They are the ones who will have to absorb the losses and be careful not to make the same mistakes again.

Economics 101 and the law of supply and demand apply here. The mortgage companies, not wanting to be in the housing business, are simply going to have to keep lowering the prices of the homes until there are willing buyers _ perhaps investors or young couples who have been saving responsibly and are looking forward to their first homes.

Now, regarding the borrowers. They aren't necessarily the innocent victims the media make them out to be.

Many banks claim that these borrowers are at fault by intentionally misstating incomes or lying about net assets. This was done so often that phrases have been coined for this behavior: "liar's loans" or "no doc loans." These borrowers simply got in over their heads and will have to adjust their lifestyles accordingly. Renting might be an option.

Also, some borrowers are pretty nonchalant in their behavior.

Michelle Malkin gives an example in one of her columns of a story that was in the Los Angeles Times. It was about Californians simply living in their homes for 12 months, awaiting foreclosure, saving their mortgage payments and then just walking away.

Does Washington really want to come to the rescue of these people?

Whatever the solution eventually turns out to be, hard-working, patient taxpayers who handle their finances responsibly shouldn't have to pay with their taxes to bail out people who made irresponsible decisions.

An economics professor at Temple University pointed out that 96 percent of all mortgages are being paid on a timely basis. He further points out that only 2 percent to 3 percent of all mortgage loans are in foreclosure and that the delinquency rates were higher in the 1980s than they are now.

Should the government come to the rescue of people taking irresponsible risks at the expense of responsible citizens?

I hope these responsible citizens who represent the vast majority of the electorate will make their dissatisfaction known in the voting booth.

___

Tom Sears is a professor of accounting at Hartwick College in Oneonta and was a delegate candidate for former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee in the New York primary. He can be reached at SearsT@hartwick.edu. His column appears every other week.

print this story  



Zillow
monster
autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Featured Jobs

The Neptune Diner is now accepting applications
The Neptune Diner is now accepting applications for Overnight Waitstaff Apply in Person Rt. 23 Southside....>MORE

Now Hiring ExperiencedSous Chef & Grill Cooks.
Now Hiring ExperiencedSous Chef & Grill Cooks. FT & PT. Apply in Person @ Tunnicliff Inn 607-547-9611...>MORE

Now Hiring QuickwayManager Hartwick/Oneonta NY
Now Hiring QuickwayManager Hartwick/Oneonta NY To Apply Call 607-237-4593 or email flo.kemeren@mirabito.com...>MORE

See all ads

Featured Autos

1996 Sunline Travel Trailer: 26 ft.,
1996 Sunline Travel Trailer: 26 ft., excellent shape. Everything works $3800. Call 607-278-6887 ...>MORE

Selling your car?
If you are looking for another way to advertise that you are selling your new or used vehicle, call The Daily Star Class...>MORE

Clean 03 Hyundai Elantra
Clean 03 Hyundai Elantra Front Motor Seal Needs Replacing $2250.00...>MORE

New, Used, Dealer or Individual
If you have a new or used car that you want to sell, advertise here on our Premium Auto section of our website. Whether...>MORE

See all ads

Featured Real Estate

Otego 1 bedroom upstairs off street parking
Otego 1 bedroom upstairs off street parking, credit check $600 + elec. + security. 315-491-3046...>MORE

Portlandville & Otego $400-$650/mo.
Portlandville & Otego $400-$650/mo. + Utilities Security & 1 Yr Lease.Dave @ 607-330-5703...>MORE

2 & 3 bedroom apt.'s in West End
2 & 3 bedroom apt.'s in West End with garage. No pets $600 & $725/mo + util. 432-8709 after 5pm...>MORE

Cooperstown 1 bedroom
Cooperstown 1 bedroom Garden apt. $625 & Also Lg. 1 bedroom $675. Both incl. Util. 212-725-2853...>MORE

Oneonta 1st FL Spacious
Oneonta 1st FL Spacious 1 Bed, Garage, W/D No Pets/Smoke. Quiet & Professional $695 + Util. Avail 7/1 Call Steve 607-...>MORE

See all ads

thedailystar.com
Home
Local News
Local Sports
Obituaries
Weather
Community
Police Blotter
Lifestyles
Letters to the Editor
Editorials
Columns
Community News
Forums
Contests
AP Headlines
Street Talk
Special sections
Web Extras
Archive
Photos
Video
Births
Step Back in Time
Support Groups
What's Going On
Communtiy Calendar

Columnists
Emily Popek
Sam Pollak
Tanya Shalor
Tom Sears
Tom Grace
Lisa Miller
Cary Brunswick
Mark Simonson
My Turn
Michele Clapperton
Additional Resources
Business Card Index
Real Estate Professionals
Stay Tuned - TV Guide
Social Networks
WUOW Radio
SUNY Oneonta Weather Cam
Breaking News Alerts

Market Place
Jobs
Cars
Classifieds
Free Coupons
Yellow Pages
Place an ad
Employment Opportunties
Cafe Press: The Daily Star Store
Circulation
Subscriptions
Renew Subscription
Use EZ Pay
Vacation Stop
Delivery Feedback
Address Change
Weekly Star Locations

Services
Report a website issue
Contact Information
Advertise with us
Website Design
Photo Reprints
Can't find an article
Full Page Reprint

Reader Submissions
Birth Announcement
Community Event Announcement
Wedding / Engagement Announcement
News Tip or Story Idea
Photos
Letter to the Editor
Closing, Delay or Cancellation






Partners
Prom dresses Fundraisers Full Tilt kids bedding
Concert Tickets Speedy-paydayloans and Cash Advance Wireless broadband Cash Advance Car Rental Avis - Hertz - Europcar
Casinos Canda Online Gambling News Online Casino Place Your Link Here! Payday Loan
Geld Reverse Phone Number Lookup

 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
Advertiser index