The Daily Star, Oneonta, NY - otsego county news, delaware county news, oneonta news, oneonta sports


October 25, 2013

'Debate' wasn't much of one|

“To discuss opposing reasons; argue.”

That’s the definition given by Webster’s New World Collegiate Dictionary of the word “debate.” 

By this standard, the recent event hosted by the Oneonta Area League of Women Voters barely qualified. 

This is certainly not the League’s fault. The not-for-profit, nonpartisan organization put on an organized, professional and informative event at SUNY Oneonta on Wednesday night, featuring candidates seeking to represent the town of Oneonta. 

It’s not the audience’s fault, either. The event was well-attended, and numerous people asked thoughtful questions on issues such as economic development, shared services, MOSA and Otsego Manor. 

And the three candidates for town justice are off the hook, since they were only there to make statements. 

But between county board candidates Janet Hurley-Quackenbush and Dan Buttermann, and town board candidates Brett Holleran, Patricia Jacob, Andrew Stammel and Fred Volpe, the words most frequently heard were “I agree.” There was a distinct lack of “opposing reasons,” and nothing that could be called an argument. 

It was, in short, a love-fest. 

Now, for those of you who are (quite rightfully) tired of bitter, partisan battles, gridlock and mudslinging, you may be saying, “Good!” We have no desire to see personal attacks, or argument for its own sake. But we do want, and voters need, to understand what sets these candidates apart from each other. 

Voters need to hear, “Here’s why you should vote for me and not the other guy (or gal).” By and large, on Wednesday night, that didn’t happen. 

The candidates did speak about their respective backgrounds. But without specific statements along the lines of “As your county (or town) board representative, I would do x, y and z,” how are voters supposed to evaluate those backgrounds? 

Text Only

Additional Content
Join the Debate
Additional Resources
CNHI News Service

Is Israel justified to conduct its military campaign against the Hamas in Gaza?

Undecided/no opinion
     View Results